Skip Navigation

10 Sci-Fi Movies that Deserve to be Made

21/10/07

Filed under:

26 comments

Hollywood and sci-fi movies make uneasy bedfellows. The sci-fi genre seems to contribute disproportionately to blockbuster Hollywood franchises (Star Wars, The Matrix, Aliens, Terminator etc.), yet convincing Hollywood to take a chance on, and produce a good sci-fi movie is tougher than squeezing blood from a stone.

The sci-fi genre in particular is hard hit by Hollywood's inability to gamble on anything but a guaranteed cash-cow. And when the figures don't come in Hollywood cries foul. Film studios habitually complain about plunging viewing figures, laying blame at the feet of anything other than the real culprit - they crap they continually release.

Journal Feed

The sci-fi genre is undeservedly neglected by Hollywood. Perhaps those that make the decisions simply do not understand sci-fi, but when there is a fan base as large and fanatical as sci-fi enjoys it is hard to understand why film studios do not give them what they crave.

Being the nice chap that I am, rather than chastising the film studios, I'm going to take pity on them and give them the helping hand they sorely need. There's huge demand out there for good sci-fi and precious little in the way of supply. It's time to redress the balance and give the fans what they want. This is my list of 10 sci-fi movies I believe deserve to see the light of day.

1) Serenity II

Serenity, the movie written and directed by Joss Whedon, continued the story told by his television series Firefly, and was described by many as the film that Star Wars Episodes I-III should have been.

Serenity movie poster

Serenity is a swash-buckling tale that follows the adventures of a Han-Solo-type mercenary character, who found himself on the losing side of an interstellar war. Witty, intelligent and great fun, there are a million more stories to be told in the Serenity/Firefly universe, any number of which would be suitable for the big screen.

2) Alien3 (as originally imagined)

The original script for Alien3 had what many fans wanted (and still want) to see: Aliens on Earth. Not Aliens on present-day Earth (as in the terrible Aliens versus Predator), but Aliens on Ripley's Earth, with both high-tech gun-toting marines and Aliens a-plenty coming to blows with the poor old general population caught in the middle.

Alien 3, original teaser trailer

A teaser trailer to this effect was released prior to filming began on Alien3, but the inevitable budget cutbacks and meddling on Sigourney Weaver's part resulted in the diluted mess we ended up with.

For my money, nothing could be better than Aliens set loose on a futuristic Earth, with motion-tracker carrying marines hunting them down. Can we finally get to this in Alien 5? Please?

3) Halo

A hugely popular computer game, Halo is the story of a group of marines who crash-land on a giant ring-shaped world. In this universe humanity is at war with a race of intergalactic thugs, called the Covenant, who also happen to be on this ring-shaped world in search of an artifact. Cue pulse-quickening action of epic proportions.

Master Chief, from the Halo computer game series

In a quite amazing twist of irony, film executives blamed the release of Halo 3 on the Xbox for a 27% drop in ticket sales, when only a few months earlier the Peter Jackson helmed Halo movie was shelved. Even if you buy into the lunacy that a computer game was responsible for a drop in ticket sales (it can't possibly be the poor choice of movies to watch, can it?) surely the sensible film exec would put two and two together and realise the public like Halo, and that producing a Halo movie would probably be a good idea?

Thankfully Fox have picked up the rights to Halo, which means we're likely to see the story of Master Chief and his band of marines on the big screen at some point in the future.

4) Star Wars - The Sequels

Ah, where to begin with Star Wars. Let's get one thing straight - the prequels were turkeys. All of them. They gradually became more bearable, Revenge of the Sith being the best of the bunch, but they are so woefully short of what was expected it is depressing.

Star Destroyer over Endor

For me, there are two fundamental problems with the prequels;

  • Lucas ruined the history of Star Wars. Odds are most people already had preconceived ideas of what transpired before episode IV, and Lucas spelling it out for us in such comical fashion merely served to alienate and annoy his audience. In my mind, Darth Vader was never a whiny brat, he certainly didn't hand-build C-3P0 and Midichlorians weren't used to explain away the Force.
  • It left nowhere for the story to go. Star Wars is a universe with many tales to tell. In going backwards, Lucas not only gave the story a definite ending, but an ending the entire audience was fully aware of before they got into their theatre seat.

Star Wars should have moved forwards. New stories, new characters and a new lease of life. Is it ever going to happen? Well, Lucas is the man pulling all the strings and I don't imagine him letting that happen any time soon. But we shall see.

5) Wing Commander (done properly)

The Wing Commander movie suffered from many ailments, not least of which were sub-par acting and a terrible script that was far too narrow in scope.

Wing Commander computer game render

The vast and rich Wing Commander universe brought to life in the computer games of the same name is ripe for a movie (or movies) on a grand scale. It is the story of two colossal empires duking it out on the galactic stage with vast fleets of warships, told from the perspective of one pilot (the character played by the gamer in the original computer games).

The Wing Commander series still enjoys a large and loyal fan base. All this needs is the right script and a studio brave enough to take it on. I won't hold my breathe.

6) Doom (done properly)

You know something is amiss when the budget for a computer game (Doom 3) is greater than the budget for a film based on the series. Doom the movie was a complete car crash. One Digg commenter noted that all they needed to do with Doom was cross Event Horizon with Aliens. They didn't. How they got it so wrong I'll never know.

Doom 3 computer game screenshot

Doom doesn't need great dialogue, nor characters we particularly care about. It is a splatter movie, pure and simple. Get Paul Verhoeven, or a director of his ilk at the helm and let rip with a scary-as-hell no-holds-barred frag-fest. Satisfaction guaranteed. Oh, and please don't cast the Rock as male lead.

7) Matrix - The Prequel

This is the Matrix movie I would much rather have seen over the two sub-par sequels (sorry, installments 2 and 3 in the trilogy). The war between humanity and the machines, and the subsequent subjugation of the human race.

Scene from the Animatrix, Second Renaissance

This story can draw parallels with the war between humanity and the machines in Terminator (which I won't mention here since Terminator 4 is in production), even so far as knowing that the machines ultimately triumph in both. The main difference is that it is humanity that starts the war in the Matrix, not the machines.

Unfortunately, telling this story would mean ditching the cast of the original Matrix, something that the studio would surely never agree to. Still, it is a great tale that deserves more than a 10 minute cursory glance in the Animatrix.

8) StarCraft

Another computer game that is crying out for a good script and a studio brave enough to take it on. StarCraft is a three-way struggle between the remnants of humanity, the hive-like Zerg and the psionic Protoss.

Starcraft artwork

Rumours of a StarCraft movie periodically circulate discussion boards and fan sites, but there is nothing concrete to suggest a movie will ever materialise.

Any StarCraft movie would have to be fairly epic in scope. An expensive gamble perhaps, but the material is there for the taking, not to mention an eager audience.

9) Warhammer 40k

Warhammer 40k is an interesting one. Personally I'm not interested in the turn-based table-top game but I am interested in the universe in which it is set. There are countless books and numerous computer games set in this dystopian future, where genetically-engineered super-soldiers, the Space Marines, desperately defend humanity from the onslaught of various intergalactic foes.

Warhammer 40k battle scene

There's material aplenty here from which you could pick out a good screenplay. I always imagined a futuristic version of Lord of the Rings, with battles on an equally epic scale. Unfortunately I can't imagine any studio being bold enough to take this one on.

10) Elite

I'll admit, I'm probably alone in wanting to see Elite up on the big screen. I have many a fond memory of climbing into my wireframe Cobra Mk III and trading my way across the galaxy. Docking at space stations to the sound of Blue Danube (right out of a Space Odyssey) was merely the icing on the cake.

Elite computer game screenshot

Turning Elite into a movie is not as straightforward a task as many of the other titles mentioned here, but hell, I'll have a stab at writing a screenplay if no one else fancies it?

Edit

Apologies all. Comments have been closed due to a handful of abusive idiots who are unable to post their opinion in a civilised manner.

It seems I should have written various lists categorised into novels that should be made into movies, computer games that should be made into movies and prequels, sequels and remakes. Even then the idea of computer games being made into movies is heresy for some - an affront to real sci-fi apparently.

Oh well. You can't please everyone, eh?

Comments are closed for this journal entry.

Bill Ruhsam

22 October, 2007

You don’t seem to be calling for specific movies, merely specific movie settings. What stories would you like to see?

Personally, I’d rather see new settings than rehash old ones. That way lies sequelitis and the death of good storytelling.

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

@ Bill – yes, movies in those settings, not specific stories per say, though in something like Doom, or Alien 3, the foundations of the story are already there. I certainly have my own ideas of the kind of stories I’d like to see, but this post is not about my shoddy ideas for a screenplay ;-)

I don’t believe rehashing old material necessarily leads to the death of good storytelling. It can often be an opportunity for a different take on the same idea (re-imagined Galactica versus original Galactica for example).

In any case, the story is the key, and the Worlds mentioned have ample material for a good storyteller to draw upon. I’d just like to see enjoyable films produced that are set in those Worlds.

NightSteel

22 October, 2007

While we’re on the idea of movies from video game settings, of which you mention five, try the FreeSpace universe. Descent: FreeSpace and its sequel, FreeSpace 2 were some of the last great space sims. The storylines are entertaining, the antagonists are scary, and the action is fierce.

Jim

22 October, 2007

I saw the title to the article and thought, “ooh, this should be good.” Then the first movie was “Serenity” and I knew it would be a complete waste of time and it surely was.

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

@ NightSteel – I agree. I thought the FreeSpace universe was top-notch.

@ Jim – and yet you wasted more time posting? It’s one man’s opinion. Don’t take it too seriously.

BCL

22 October, 2007

Pretty boring list. They are all the same thing: Humans battling aliens or machines. Ho-hum. It this all that you think science fiction is?

Marty

22 October, 2007

I feel obliged to point out that all your entries are either movies you didn’t like or videogames you did (or both).

Are there any science fiction stories you want?

Ryan

22 October, 2007

You know, when you jump-started your list with Firefly I thought you might have a leg to stand on.

Then you went and called Revenge of the Sith the best of the Star Wars Prequels which you seem to think got better as they went?

Unless your only definition of “better” is less Jar-jar, then I must humbly submit the opinion that your are a moron.

BTW-You forgot “Ender’s Game” as a matter of fact you don’t really seem to have anything based on a book, which is yet another reason why I doubt your intelligence.

Jim

22 October, 2007

kitsimons – I dont’ take it seriously but appparently you do, hence your ridiculous response. May I suggest you try and date? You’ll find there is a life outside your computer,

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

@ Ryan & Jim – try and stay away from the personal insults please. Like I said, one man’s opinion.

Ariel

22 October, 2007

It still amazes me that people don’t just press the little red X in the top right of their browser if they’re not interested in reading something.

Instad, they’ll read through the entire thing, think of an appropriate derrogatory remark, go through the process of posting it, and probably check back for a response.

As far as one person’s opinions go, I think this is a fine list. Grow up, folks.

Duckfan

22 October, 2007

What about some of the ‘world’ movies: – Ringworld – Dayworld – Riverworld (sorry SciFi channel) – World of Tiers

monkey

22 October, 2007

Video games always make terrible movies.

But, what about William Gibson’s Neuromancer.

Oh wait, thats a book too. :D

Josh

22 October, 2007

how about ender’s game series and the foundation series. those are sci-fi gold. and foundation is just perfect for a movie. also other asimov movies. not the annoying i-robot with will smith but something good like the robot stories w elijah bailey. or the infinities.
and seriously, revenge of the sith was the best? the skywalker-kenobi duel was good but no, the first of the prequels was the best. which really isnt saying too much. thats wat i told mcgregor when i met him in madrid and he agreed w me.
oh and a battlestar galactica movie…thats what we need.

J

22 October, 2007

Please, these are NOT sci-fi movies. All you really want to see is a bunch of X-box/PS games thrown up on a giant screen.
Am I the only one who thinks mommy’s little darling should learn how to read?

Josh

22 October, 2007

The Homeworld PC game would make a great movie. A very cerebral movie, but a good one i think.

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

Absolutely agree Ariel.

@ Monkey – I haven’t read Neuromancer. Worth checking out I presume?

@ Josh – I thought about Galactica. Personally I think it would be nice to see a Galactica movie after the TV series has been wrapped up, and a story that doesn’t interfere with its plot. The first Cylon war with a young Adama would be nice to see.

@ J – the notion that you can only enjoy sci-fi from a book is a little elitist, no? Remember, this is only a top 10 list. It's somewhat presumptuous to assume I don't read sci-fi based upon that.

Josh

22 October, 2007

they’re already doing a teaser series of the first cylon war with a young adama. it’s on friday’s at like 9 or 10 on the sci-fi channel. they’re 2 minutes long. crazy 2 minutes tho lol

Gretzinator

22 October, 2007

For movie plots galore, anything from Niven and/or Pournelle would work fine. Man-Kzin wars 1-XXV, anyone? I’d sit through a few seasons of that. Long ARM of Gil Hamilton, if you’re looking for a suspense/ detective novel, and give someone a real gruesome view of socialized medicine. Mote in god’s eye, Foot Fall, or any of the Known Space. ‘Fallen Angels’ would be an interesting one, with all of the ‘sky is falling’ panic going on now. I suspect he wrote ‘Oath of Fealty’ after a bad run in with a Homeowner’s association.

It sucks that the only thing from Larry Niven that’s been made into screenplay is a rewrite of ‘Kzinti Weapon’ for the animated star trek series. That, and stealing ‘ringworld’ for the Halo game. Hey, did I really just see a shadow square go by?

Ariel

22 October, 2007

I would love to see something from the Coldfire trilogy by CS Friedman, if they could do it right and stick to the plot and character types.

As far as prequels/sequels that would be awesome? I’d have to put my vote in for Equalibrium .5 or II. I’d pay full movie prices at the Drafthouse for that :)

johnny

22 October, 2007

agree with gretzinator:

ringworld, mote in god’s eye and also the Gaea series by Varley

Duckfan

22 October, 2007

And while I think about it – how about finishing “Space, Above and Beyond”

Malloy

22 October, 2007

Make a movie out of an Iain M. Banks Culture novel and you’d have something worth going to see.

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

It amazes me that some people think it’s acceptable to post abusive comments. I’m more than happy for people to voice their opinion. Please just keep it polite.

@ Duckfan – SAAB definitely deserves to be finished. It still annoys me how that series was cut short.

ross

22 October, 2007

it seems like the sci fi here only involves ‘fragging’ and epic space battles. i think the best elements of sci far are not based around special effects but rather emphasize humanity. it doesn’t make sense to me, then, to say the best sci fi movies that could be made revolve around video games and other franchises that center mostly on blood lust. i second the call for asimov material.

kitsimons

22 October, 2007

@ Ross – agreed. I’m not saying those listed represent the best sci-fi movies that could be made. They’re simply movies I’d like to see. I’d just as much like to see more Asimov.

Kitsimons...

Photo of Simon Kitson

...is the online home of Simon Kitson, a web designer with a healthy enthusiasm for standards-compliant, accessible design and a penchant for blogging about nothing in particular.

Notes

Notes Archive