Living With Leopard
I've had Apple's OS X Leopard running on my machine for a few weeks now; plenty enough time to genuinely impressed with the new features and plenty enough time to be annoyed by various other aspects of the new operating system.
All said and done, Leopard was well worth the upgrade from Tiger. However, Leopard is far from perfect. Indeed, some aspects of Leopard could be considered a step backwards from Tiger. Here's my run down of the good, the bad and the ugly in OS X 10.5.
The Good
New Features
Spaces is one new feature I didn't think would make much of a difference for me. I'd gotten into the habit of hiding applications when not needed, and thought it would be hard to abandon that habit. I was wrong. Spaces is brilliantly executed and makes flicking between applications even more of a breeze.
Time Machine certainly lives up to hype. Previously I was very remiss when it came to making backups, but now I'm making use of the Lacie brick plugged into my Mac.
Quick Look is also very handy, when I remember to use it.
As for the other major new features, such as Stacks and Coverflow, I can't say I've found them particularly useful. Not to say they aren't useful, but they certainly haven't grabbed me and got me using them in the same manner that something like Spaces has.
Elsewhere
Features aside, from a performance standpoint the machine really does feel quicker. I don't have any benchmarks to compare Tiger and Leopard on my Mac Pro, but Photoshop is noticeably brisker in pretty much all areas. Overall there seems to be less stalling when working with OS X - I certainly see less of the spinning beach ball in Leopard than I did in Tiger.
From a stability point of view, Leopard is pretty solid from what I've seen. I've not had a single kernel panic as yet and all my applications, 3rd-party or otherwise, work just fine. I have to say I was somewhat surprised at Leopard's stability given it is a first release. I recall the odd kernel panic when I installed the newly released Tiger, so it's nice that Leopard is so robust right out of the gates.
The Bad
The Finder, unfortunately, is still flawed. Most frustratingly for me, folders no longer remember their view settings - even when pinned in view options. Whether or not this is an oversight I don't know, but I can't think of a single reason to why Apple would purposefully remove this feature.

I'm not a fan of the new Dock, in particular the way collapsed stacks are handled. Stacks on the Dock place the icon of first item in the stack at the top, so essentially all you see is the icon belonging to that file. In the above screenshot, the Word icon is my downloads folder, while the Address Book icon is my applications folder. This behaviour is utterly and totally infuriating. Thankfully there are workarounds, though I would much prefer Apple come up with a better thought-out solution.
Sticking with the Dock, I'm not keen on the new lights indicating an open application. The little triangles used in Tiger weren't exactly perfect, but at least they contrasted with the Dock background. The blue blobs of light in Leopard are harder to spot and deviate from an otherwise unified and cohesive user interface.
The Ugly
Finally, in the Dock (not doing too well, is it?) there is a strange new separator. Lord only knows what this is supposed to be - it looks like squashed road markings to me. In any case, it's an unsightly aberration in what is an otherwise beautiful interface. It is a testament to how well designed the OS X interface is, and how much I take it for granted, that I am picking on something as minor as a separator. Still, the Dock is one of the most prominent aspects of the interface. Apple could have done better.
Comments are closed for this journal entry.
Kitsimons...
![]()
...is the online home of Simon Kitson, a web designer with a healthy enthusiasm for standards-compliant, accessible design and a penchant for blogging about nothing in particular.
Notes
- Nice Nike Football ad from Madonna's better half.
- Top marks for the realigned BBC News website, bringing it more in line with the lovely new, jQuery driven, BBC homepage.
Beautiful full-screen image browsing served up by the snazzy PicLens plug-in. Impressive, though practicality is debatable.- Yahoo shifts to search the
semantic web
. Potentially huge, and very welcome news for usstandards nuts
.
The Coke Zero Game. Latest masterpiece from the infuriatingly talented North Kingdom.
It's sites like the Red Bull Flight Lab that remind you what Flash is for. Brilliant application and an awful lot of fun.- Rejoice! The new Indiana Jones trailer has finally made an appearance. Can't wait.
- Help the Email Standards Project get Google's attention in the hope they will finally improve Gmail's awful rendering of HTML email.
- Awesome panoramic view of the Airbus A380 cockpit interior. This is the super-future.
- Excellent article from accessibility supremo Roger Johansson on how inappropriate, or overuse, of HTML features meant to aid accessibility can actually have the opposite effect.









Simon
23 November, 2007
Thanks for posting this – I’m on the cusp of upgrading, so it’s good to get a peek of Leopard in action. Glad to hear that it’s more stable, been having instability problems with v10.4.11, getting pretty sick of the spinning beachball.
I’m with you on the design, it’s odd, the separator looks like a runway strip or something off of Buck Rogers. I’m not feeling the flavour of the new dock, the reflections under the icons look to complicate things and mean that the dock intrudes further into the viewing area than before, which can be a pain if you ever find yourself using Quark because it competes for space with the Quark properties palette. A pretty minor gripe though ; )
kitsimons
3 December, 2007
Glad it helps mate. Leopard’s definitely worth the upgrade from Tiger IMO, in spite of the odd UI foible.
Anonymous
16 December, 2007
That ‘road marking’ thing actually allows you to adjust the size of your dock on-the-fly.
Put your mouse over it and the cursor should change to arrows – then adjust as you please.
I have my dock on the left (wide screen). To change the dock to something a little slicker:
Mac:~ kit$ defaults write com.apple.dashboard mcx-disabled -boolean YES killall Dock
Repeat with -boolean NO to turn it back on again.
kitsimons
17 December, 2007
It’s handy being able to adjust the dock from the dock, I just wish they’d made it sit more comfortably with the whole Leopard UI… But who’s perfect eh?